Lot has been said on Mandal II. There is hue and cry over proposal of quota for OBC's in IITs and IIMs. Everyone has given his/her viewpoints.
Here I wont like to discuss, what is right or wrong, but possible cultural and social impact of this decision. Till now, no one has talked about the possible relationship among students in these pre-eminent institutes, their prospects after education and challenges they going to face in present education system if this proposal is implemented in its present form.
From my experience I could say that most of the quota category students are not open about their background. They always try to hide it from other students because most of the general category students never find reservation justified. So if this proposal is implemented, it means every second student in these institutes will belong to any of these reservation categories. I cant even think of the reaction of students who are selected on the basis of merit, if they find every second student hasn't put the same amount of hard work as they have put. But I am pretty sure; this reaction is not going to be normal and acceptable.
Even today, general category students don’t accept reservation. And in IIT's, they move and interact in different groups. I am afraid that 50:50 divide might lead to cultural divide between these two groups.
Campus placements: critical period in every student’s life. More than 90% of the organizations that recruit graduates from these institutes belong to private sector. So lets suppose at the time of final selection, if a choice comes down to 'general' student and 'quota' student, with other factors being same, there is clear likelihood that the recruiting company will choose the 'general' student. Reason is simple: There is a huge difference in the intellectual level of both students at the time of entrance.
Implementing similar level of reservation in private sector jobs is still a distant dream. Either these companies will stop coming to IIT or they will recruit off campus.
Another valid observation is whether these institutes are capable of handling this decision. How they going to make sure that the student from OBC's perform as per standards. Because just ensuring an admission wont help them in longer term.
Today, every aspirant who fights hard to secure a seat wont let it go that easily.